Please Help me decide which model to purchase!
 

Hello all,

I am interested in getting a Porsche in the 20K-30K range. Doing a little research on available cars for sell, I found that I would be looking at either getting a 2000-2003 Porsche 911 Carerra/4/4S or a 2005-08 Cayman S. Unfortunately, the 911 Turbo is a little out of my price range.
Few Questions:
-which would give me a more enjoyable driving experience?
-which is easier to maintain?
-which exact model would be more suitable?
-problems I might have with certain models?
-which has more of a lasting value?
-Any tips or personal preferences y'all might have

Any tips, thoughts, concerns would be GREATLY appreciated as I would love to hear from anybody who is already an owner to help me make my decision to join the Porsche community!

Thanks!